Protractor vs Selenium | Top 10 Key Differences

Protractor vs Selenium | Top 10 Key Differences

Ensuring quality user interfaces (UIs) across multiple browsers and devices is essential, especially when more and more businesses are moving online. This is where automated testing tools like Selenium and Protractor help, allowing developers and testers to streamline the testing process. 

However, choosing the right tool for the job can be a challenging decision and requires a thorough understanding of the key differences between Protractor and Selenium. Selenium enables simulating user interactions, validating UI elements, and running test cases across various browsers. On the other hand, Protractor builds upon Selenium’s foundation, specifically targeting AngularJS applications. 

Now, let’s delve into the article that highlights key insights on Protractor vs Selenium. This article will help you understand these automated testing tools in detail and provide the best alternative tool that combines the powers of Protractor and Selenium into one.

You should check out the complete comparison of popular test automation tools.

What is Protractor?

Protractor is a framework specifically designed for testing AngularJS web applications. It leverages the core functionalities and architecture of Selenium but adds a layer of Angular-specific features and optimizations tailored to streamline testing within this framework.

Here’s why Protractor stands out:

  1. Seamless Integration with Angular: Protractor understands the intricacies of Angular’s architecture, including its components, directives, and services. This allows it to interact with these elements directly, eliminating the need for complex workarounds and simplifying test scripts.
  2. Enhanced Testing Capabilities: Protractor offers functionalities like waiting for Angular elements to load, interacting with dynamic elements, and testing asynchronous operations. These features ensure your tests accurately reflect the real-world behavior of your Angular application.
  3. Built-in Support for AngularJS Features: Protractor provides built-in support for testing AngularJS-specific features like routing, dependency injection, and filters. This eliminates the need to write custom code for these interactions, saving you time and effort.

While Protractor excels in Angular testing, its focus makes it less versatile compared to Selenium for broader web application testing needs.

Protractor vs Selenium: Exploring Features, Advantages, And Drawbacks

While Protractor is known for testing AngularJS applications, its feature set extends beyond simple framework compatibility. Let’s explore the unique functionalities, advantages, and potential drawbacks of Protractor.

Features of Protractor:

  1. Built-in AngularJS support: Protractor effortlessly interacts with Angular elements like components, directives, and services, eliminating the need for custom workarounds.
  2. Enhanced waiting mechanisms: It provides built-in waiting strategies that automatically handle asynchronous operations within Angular, ensuring test stability.
  3. Page Object Model (POM) facilitation: Protractor encourages the use of POM, promoting modular and maintainable test code.
  4. Cross-browser testing: Tests can be executed across various browsers like Chrome, Firefox, and Safari.
  5. Integration with popular frameworks: Protractor seamlessly integrates with testing frameworks like Jasmine and Mocha.

Advantages of Protractor:

  1. Faster testing for Angular applications: Protractor leverages its tailored feature set for faster and more efficient testing of Angular projects.
  2. Improved accuracy and stability: Built-in waiting mechanisms and Angular-specific functionalities ensure tests accurately reflect application behavior.
  3. Maintainable test code: The use of POM leads to well-structured and easily understandable test scripts.
  4. Community support: Protractor enjoys a dedicated community providing resources and support.

Drawbacks of Protractor:

  1. Limited scope: Protractor primarily focuses on AngularJS testing, limiting its use to broader web applications.
  2. Steeper learning curve: Understanding Angular-specific aspects might require additional learning for testers unfamiliar with the framework.
  3. Possible performance limitations: Performance issues have been reported in older browsers like Internet Explorer.
  4. Reliance on Selenium: Any underlying issues in Selenium can affect Protractor’s performance.

By carefully considering these features, advantages, and drawbacks, you can determine if Protractor aligns with your specific testing needs and project requirements.

What companies use Protractor?

Protractor, due to its focused design, caters to a specific category of companies seeking efficient and effective web UI testing solutions. Here’s a breakdown of the ideal candidates for Protractor adoption:

Angular-Centric Businesses:

  1. Companies heavily invested in AngularJS: If your core web application relies on AngularJS, Protractor’s deep integration and understanding of the framework offer unparalleled testing efficiency and accuracy.
  2. Businesses building single-page applications (SPAs) with Angular: Protractor’s ability to handle dynamic elements and asynchronous operations within Angular SPAs ensures your testing reflects real-world user interactions.
  3. Organizations maintaining legacy AngularJS applications: Protractor seamlessly integrates with existing AngularJS code, reducing the need for extensive refactoring during testing processes.

Companies Seeking Specialized Testing Tools:

  1. Teams requiring in-depth testing of Angular-specific features: Protractor’s built-in support for routing, dependency injection, and filters simplifies testing these unique Angular functionalities.
  2. Organizations prioritizing rapid development and testing cycles: Protractor’s features like built-in waiting mechanisms and POM facilitation streamline test creation and execution, speeding up development lifecycles.
  3. Companies with limited testing resources: Protractor’s ease of use and Angular-specific features allow testers with less framework expertise to contribute effectively, optimizing resource utilization.

Companies Valuing Community and Support:

  1. Organizations seeking active community support: Protractor enjoys a dedicated community providing ongoing development, resources, and troubleshooting assistance.
  2. Businesses leveraging open-source tools and frameworks: Protractor’s open-source nature aligns well with companies favoring open-source solutions for cost-efficiency and transparency.

What tools integrate with Protractor?

Protractor, while powerful for AngularJS testing, can be further enhanced by integrating with other tools that address specific testing needs or complement its functionalities. Here, we explore three such tools and how they seamlessly integrate with Protractor:

Cucumber for Behavioral Driven Development (BDD):

  • Integration: Protractor integrates with Cucumber through libraries like protractor-cucumber-framework. This allows for writing test scenarios in plain language, promoting collaboration between developers, testers, and stakeholders.
  • Benefits: Cucumber improves test readability and maintainability, fosters clearer communication, and aligns tests with user stories, promoting BDD practices within your Angular project.

Allure Framework for Reporting and Visualization:

  • Integration: Protractor can generate Allure-compatible test reports using libraries like protractor-allure-reporter. These reports offer detailed execution summaries, screenshots, and step-by-step breakdowns for insightful analysis.
  • Benefits: Allure provides visually appealing and interactive reports, facilitating easier identification of test failures and root cause analysis, ultimately improving test debugging and efficiency.

Appium for Mobile Testing:

  • Integration: Protractor integrates with Appium through libraries like appium-doctor and appium-webdriver. This allows leveraging Protractor’s testing expertise for mobile applications built with AngularJS frameworks.
  • Benefits: This integration enables testing your Angular-based mobile apps with familiar Protractor syntax, streamlining your testing workflow and ensuring consistent testing across web and mobile platforms.

What is Selenium?

Selenium is a robust and versatile test automation framework, known for streamlining web UI testing across diverse applications and browsers. Its core functionalities revolve around enabling user interactions, validating UI elements, and executing test cases on various platforms. Unlike Protractor’s focus on Angular, Selenium caters to a wider range of web technologies, making it a valuable tool for organizations with varied testing needs.

Selenium offers several key advantages:

  1. Language Flexibility: It provides bindings for popular programming languages like Python, Java, C#, and Ruby, allowing developers and testers to leverage their preferred skillsets.
  2. Cross-Browser and Cross-Device Testing: Selenium supports numerous browsers and operating systems, ensuring your applications function seamlessly across various environments.
  3. Customization and Control: Its flexible framework enables custom scripting and integration with other tools, offering granular control over testing processes.
  4. Open-Source Nature: The open-source model eliminates licensing fees and fosters a large, active community that contributes to its development and provides support resources.

However, it’s important to remember that Selenium’s broader scope might require more development effort compared to tools tailored for specific frameworks like Protractor. You can check out the complete list of Selenium alternatives.

Selenium – Features, Advantages, and Drawbacks

Selenium, the versatile web UI testing framework, boasts a plethora of features and functionalities. However, it’s essential to understand its strengths and weaknesses to make informed decisions for your testing needs.

Features of Selenium:

  1. Grid for Distributed Testing: Enables parallel execution of test scripts across multiple machines for faster testing of complex applications.
  2. Cross-browser and Cross-device Testing: Run tests on various browsers and operating systems, ensuring compatibility across platforms.
  3. Multiple Language Support: Leverage popular programming languages like Python, Java, C#, and Ruby for script development.
  4. Page Object Model (POM) Support: Structure tests efficiently by separating data, locators, and logic for better maintainability.
  5. Integration with Testing Frameworks: Seamlessly integrate with popular frameworks like JUnit, NUnit, and TestNG for enhanced testing capabilities.
  6. Custom Scripting Flexibility: Craft tailored scripts for specific testing scenarios beyond pre-built functionalities.

Advantages of Selenium:

  1. Broad Scope: Test diverse web applications and technologies, catering to a wide range of testing needs.
  2. Cost-Effective: Open-source nature eliminates licensing fees, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious organizations.
  3. Active Community Support: Benefit from a large and active community providing resources, troubleshooting assistance, and ongoing development.
  4. Flexibility and Customization: Adapt testing procedures to specific needs through custom scripting and integration with various tools.
  5. Continuous Innovation: Enjoy ongoing development and new feature additions thanks to the active community engagement.

Drawbacks of Selenium:

  1. Learning Curve: Mastering Selenium requires understanding its functionalities and syntax, potentially demanding initial learning investment.
  2. Maintenance Effort: Custom scripting and framework integration might necessitate more maintenance compared to simpler tools.
  3. Limited Built-in Reporting: Requires external tools for detailed test reporting and visualization, adding an extra step to the process.
  4. No Direct Mobile App Testing: While Appium integration allows mobile testing, it requires additional configuration and expertise.
  5. Potential Complexity for Beginners: The vast feature set might overwhelm users new to web UI testing, requiring a gradual learning process.

What companies use Selenium?

Selenium, unlike Protractor’s laser focus on Angular, casts a broader net. Its robust framework and vast language support attract a diverse range of companies seeking efficient and effective web UI testing across various applications. Here’s a look at the typical user profile:

Companies with Diverse Web Application Needs:

  1. Organizations testing a variety of web applications: Selenium supports a wide range of web technologies, making it suitable for companies with diverse application landscapes, from simple HTML pages to complex web portals.
  2. Businesses requiring cross-browser and cross-device testing: Selenium’s compatibility with numerous browsers and operating systems allows companies to ensure their applications function seamlessly across various platforms.
  3. Organizations seeking language flexibility: Selenium offers bindings for popular programming languages like Python, Java, C#, and Ruby, catering to different development team preferences and skillsets.

Companies Prioritizing Customization and Control:

  1. Organizations needing fine-grained control over test automation: Selenium’s flexible framework allows for custom scripting and integration with other tools, providing granular control over testing processes.
  2. Businesses requiring integration with existing testing infrastructure: Selenium seamlessly integrates with various testing frameworks and CI/CD pipelines, enabling smooth adaptation into existing testing workflows.
  3. Organizations with complex testing scenarios: Selenium’s vast capabilities address diverse testing needs, including functional testing, performance testing, and accessibility testing.

Companies Focused on Open-Source Solutions:

  1. Organizations seeking cost-effective testing solutions: Selenium’s open-source nature eliminates licensing fees, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious companies.
  2. Businesses valuing community support and active development: Selenium enjoys a large and active community that contributes to its ongoing development and provides support resources.
  3. Companies prioritizing transparency and security of testing tools: The open-source nature of Selenium allows for code inspection and modification, ensuring transparency and security for organizations with specific concerns.

While Selenium offers immense flexibility, its broader scope might require more development effort compared to tools like Protractor tailored for specific frameworks.

What tools integrate with Selenium?

Selenium’s robust framework can be further amplified by integrating with other tools that address specific testing needs or augment its core functionalities. Here, we explore three such tools and their seamless integration with Selenium:

TestNG Framework:

Integration: Selenium WebDriver can be directly integrated with TestNG through annotations, eliminating the need for additional configurations.

Benefits:

  1. Simplified test organization: Groups and prioritizes tests effectively using features like test suites and annotations.
  2. Flexible reporting: Generates detailed reports with execution summaries, pass/fail statistics, and logging capabilities.
  3. Parallel test execution: Enables faster testing by running tests concurrently across multiple threads.

JUnit Framework:

Integration: Selenium WebDriver integrates with JUnit through libraries like selenium-java.

Benefits:

  1. Seamless integration with Java development: Familiar syntax and structure for Java developers.
  2. Simple test creation: Annotations like @Test make test definition straightforward.
  3. Extensive community support: Abundant resources and support available.

Cucumber for BDD Integration with Selenium:

Integration: Combines Selenium’s testing capabilities with Cucumber’s Behavior Driven Development (BDD) approach. Libraries like protractor-cucumber-framework or cucumber-jvm enable writing test scenarios in plain language, promoting collaboration and understanding between developers, testers, and stakeholders.

Benefits:

  1. Improved communication and collaboration: Plain language tests enhance communication and bridge the gap between technical and non-technical teams.
  2. Focus on user stories: Aligns tests with user stories, promoting BDD practices and ensuring tests reflect user needs.
  3. Increased test readability and maintainability: Descriptive scenarios improve test clarity and simplify future updates.
  4. Flexible language options: Supports various languages like Java, Python, and Ruby, accommodating diverse preferences.

Table Comparison: Protractor vs Selenium

Here’s a complete tabular comparison between Protractor and Selenium that will help you make an informed choice.

FeatureProtractorSelenium
Primary FocusAngularJS web applicationsWide range of web applications and technologies
Framework TypeBuilt on top of Selenium WebDriverStandalone framework
Language SupportPrimarily JavaScriptMultiple languages (Python, Java, C#, Ruby, etc.)
Testing ApproachSpecifically designed for AngularJS elements and featuresSupports various testing approaches (functional, performance, accessibility)
Built-in Waiting MechanismsOffers automatic waiting for Angular elements to loadRequires manual implementation of waiting logic
Page Object Model (POM) SupportEncourages and simplifies POM usageSupports POM, but requires more manual configuration
Cross-Browser TestingSupports major browsers (Chrome, Firefox, Safari, IE)Supports even more browsers and operating systems
Community and ResourcesDedicated AngularJS community, but smaller overallLarger and more active community, vast number of resources
Learning CurveSteeper learning curve for testers unfamiliar with AngularJSLearning curve varies based on chosen language and testing experience
Flexibility and CustomizationLess flexible due to specific focus, limited customization optionsMore flexible and customizable due to broader scope

Protractor With Selenium

While Selenium boasts impressive versatility, Protractor shines when dealing specifically with AngularJS applications. Here’s why and how you can leverage them together:

Why Protractor with Selenium?

  1. Targeted Expertise: Protractor’s deep understanding of AngularJS elements and features streamlines testing, eliminates the need for custom workarounds, and ensures tests accurately reflect your application’s behavior.
  2. Enhanced Testing Capabilities: Protractor’s built-in waiting mechanisms, handling of asynchronous operations, and support for AngularJS-specific functionalities like routing and dependency injection contribute to robust and stable testing.
  3. Seamless Integration: Protractor is built on top of Selenium, inheriting its core functionalities and compatibility with various browsers and testing frameworks like Jasmine and Mocha, allowing you to leverage existing knowledge and tools.

How to Use Protractor with Selenium?

  1. Set Up Selenium WebDriver: Install and configure Selenium WebDriver based on your preferred language and testing environment.
  2. Integrate Protractor: Use libraries like protractor-selenium-webdriver to establish the connection between Selenium and Protractor.
  3. Write Your Tests: Create test scripts using Protractor’s syntax, leveraging its built-in features and functionalities for interacting with AngularJS elements.
  4. Execute and Analyze: Run your tests using libraries like protractor-runner and analyze results to identify and fix any issues.

Remember, Protractor acts as a layer of specialization a top Selenium’s foundation. By understanding their strengths and utilizing them together, you can achieve efficient and accurate testing specifically tailored to your AngularJS applications.

Protractor vs. Selenium: Which is Best for You?

Deciding between Protractor and Selenium depends on your testing needs and project setup. Here’s a quick breakdown:

Choose Protractor if:

  1. Your core application is built with AngularJS: Protractor’s intimate understanding of Angular elements and features ensures tests accurately reflect your application’s behavior, saving you time and effort.
  2. You value built-in waiting mechanisms and Angular-specific functionalities: These features simplify test creation and maintenance, especially if your team is less familiar with manual waiting logic.
  3. You need a dedicated community for AngularJS testing: Protractor enjoys a focused community providing resources and support specific to AngularJS testing challenges.

Choose Selenium if:

  1. You need broader testing scope beyond AngularJS: Selenium supports a wider range of web technologies, making it suitable for diverse applications.
  2. You require deeper customization and control: Selenium’s flexibility allows for fine-grained control over testing processes and integration with various tools.
  3. Your team has diverse programming language skills: Selenium offers language bindings for Python, Java, C#, and more, catering to different preferences.

Remember, while Protractor offers specialized advantages for AngularJS, Selenium’s wider scope and flexibility might be better suited for broader testing needs. It’s always better to consider other alternatives that combines the power of both the tools and more.

Alternatives tool to Protractor and Selenium

While both Protractor and Selenium are established tools in the web UI testing landscape, Testsigma emerges as a compelling alternative, particularly for projects that prioritize ease of use, unified testing, and cost-effectiveness.

Testsigma

Here’s a detailed comparison between Testsigma and Protractor alternatives.

Let’s delve into why Testsigma might be the right fit for you:

Why Testsigma is the best alternative to Protractor and Selenium?

  1. No-code Approach: Testsigma eliminates the need for extensive coding knowledge, allowing testers with diverse skillsets to create and maintain automated tests using plain English keywords and visual recording. This significantly reduces the learning curve and empowers wider team participation.
  2. Unified Testing Platform: Testsigma goes beyond web testing, offering comprehensive coverage for web, mobile, and API testing within a single platform. This streamlines workflows, eliminates the need for multiple tools, and provides a holistic view of your application’s health.
  3. Collaboration Features: Built-in collaboration tools like shared test repositories, discussions, and annotations promote seamless communication and teamwork between testers, developers, and stakeholders. This fosters a more collaborative testing environment.
  4. Integrations: Testsigma seamlessly integrates with popular project management, CI/CD, and bug tracking tools, enhancing workflow efficiency and data exchange across your development ecosystem.
  5. Cost-Effective: Testsigma offers both open-source and paid plans, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious teams. Additionally, the reduced reliance on coding experts can potentially lead to lower development costs.

Features that Set Testsigma Apart:

  1. AI-powered Test Maintenance: Testsigma leverages AI to automatically heal flaky tests, reducing maintenance overhead and ensuring test stability.
  2. Self-healing Tests: Tests automatically adapt to minor UI changes, minimizing the need for manual updates and improving test resilience.
  3. Data-driven Testing: Utilize external data sources to parameterize tests for diverse scenarios, enhancing test coverage and efficiency.
  4. Visual Testing: Capture screenshots and recordings during test execution for visual regression testing and easier debugging.
  5. Detailed Reporting: Generate comprehensive reports with execution logs, screenshots, and analytics for insightful test results and performance analysis.

Sign up for free trial

Try out Testsigma

Conclusion

To sum up, both Protractor and Selenium offer valuable tools for web UI testing, but their strengths lie in different areas. Protractor’s laser focus on AngularJS shines in projects built with this framework, providing efficient testing through its deep understanding of Angular elements and built-in functionalities. However, its specialization comes at the cost of limited flexibility and broader application support.

On the other hand, Selenium’s versatility makes it a powerhouse for diverse testing needs. Its vast language support, cross-platform compatibility, and customization options cater to a wide range of web technologies and testing approaches. However, its broader scope requires more setup and potentially steeper learning curve compared to Protractor’s targeted approach.

Ultimately, the “best” tool depends on your specific project requirements, team expertise, and preferred testing approach.

Here’s another comparison of the Playwright alternatives that you may be interested in.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Selenium better than Protractor?

Protractor is a specialized adaption of Selenium. Selenium shines in its versatility, supporting diverse web technologies, languages, and testing approaches, making it ideal for complex and broad testing needs. Protractor, on the other hand, built on top of Selenium, specializes in AngularJS applications. Its deep understanding of Angular elements and features, along with built-in functionalities, streamlines testing and ensures accuracy for Angular projects. If you are only looking for an angular testing use case, you should go with Protractor. Otherwise if you think your needs go beyond Angular testing, consider Selenium or alternatives like Testsigma.


Test automation made easy

Start your smart continuous testing journey today with Testsigma.

SHARE THIS BLOG

RELATED POSTS


Cypress vs Jest | Top 15 Key Differences
Cypress vs Jest | Top 15 Key Differences
Cypress vs Protractor | What are the differences?
Cypress vs Protractor | What are the differences?
Top 10 Functionize Alternatives and Competitors
Top 10 Functionize Alternatives and Competitors