Testomat vs Qase – A Detailed Software Comparison

Managing the tests is one of the challenging tasks in Software Testing. As the features evolve and change as per the user requirements and business evolve the use case may change. Testers need to update test cases in all the places. Additionally, managing test case versions, maintaining the automation vs manual test cases, and creating the test execution report require considerable time and effort. Testers may easily be distracted by these additional tasks, apart from their core goal to perform the testing. Having a good Test Management System helps to solve such challenges easily with reduced effort. Testomat, Qase, and Testsigma are the most popularly used Test management tools. Let’s compare Testomat vs Qase in detail.

Testomat vs Qase – Overview

What is Testomat?

Testomat is a test management tool that helps to manage the automation and manual test cases in one place. It unites Business Analysts, Developers, Quality Assurance People, and non-tech stakeholders in a single flow to maximize the synergy of testing efforts and increase productivity. Testomat is a proprietary and cloud-based tool. As it is a cloud-based tool it reduces the infrastructure setup and maintenance effort. 

What is Qase?

Qase is a proprietary tool for managing the QA process and maintaining the test cases. It supports managing, maintaining, tracking, execution, and reporting under one umbrella which can help to deliver quality products faster to the market with ease.  Additionally, it supports integration with many different tools including Jira, CI/CD tools, and other bug-tracking tools that help to streamline the all-testing activity in one place

What is Testsigma?

Testsigma is all in one AI-driven tool to manage manual test cases and automate the test cases with a no-code platform. Testsigma provides the exclusive feature for managing manual test cases with Test Management System (TMS). Using this feature one can create test suites, test cases, and test runs and pull the reports on demand. Dashboards and shareable reports are one of the unique features of TMS. It also provides integration with popular tools including Jira and other popular tools. Testsigma uses AI to reduce the effort of testers while creating the test cases.

Testomat vs Qase – Feature and Limitations

Features of Testomat

Testomat has many unique features, it provides a complete platform to manage the testing life cycle. From the planning phase to the execution phase, one can manage everything related to QA under a single platform. Below is the list of Testomat features

• Testomat supports a complete test management life cycle such as planning, design, execution, and reporting.
• It allows automated and manual test cases in one platform.
• Integration with Test automation tools allows the execution of the tests from Testomat with different test automation tools and reports will be updated automatically.
• Automatically generates the reports, no manual work is needed.
• Testomat can also be integrated with popular CI/CD tools like Bamboo, GitHub, Jenkins, CircleCI, and GitLab.
• Pre-built template with Gherkin editors accelerates the test case creation.
• Easy to execute the manual test cases by grouping them.
• Testomat supports integration with Jira for instant bug reporting.
• In-built reporting and analytics such as the number of defects created, flaky tests, slow tests, etc.
• Supports Agile methodology with in-sprint testing. Read here – agile test management
• It also supports Multiple project management with multiple teams.

Limitations of Testomat

Testomat is a comparatively new tool to the market, the features are being actively added to the platform. However, as of today, there are many limitations to the tool.

• Testomat setup can be complex for small teams as it demands technical expertise to integrate.
• Testomat provides many features under the platform, which increases the learning curve. It may be difficult for a beginner to understand and use the tools.
• As the test suite grows users may face performance issues while executing test cases and generating the reports.
• It supports integration with many tools however integration requires technical expertise.
• Though it supports multiple projects and teams, as the team grows it can bring scalability issues, users may face challenges in using this tool.
• It is a modern tool and it lacks the legacy tool integration. Organizations using legacy tools may find it challenging to integrate with their ecosystem.
• As it is a cloud-based tool, it requires good internet connectivity to work all the features seamlessly.

Features of Qase

Qase is relatively new to the market, it started in the year 2018 and since then, it has made a lot of improvements focusing on the customer. It has quickly captured the market and gained many popular organizations as a client due to its unique features. Below are some of the features of Qase

• Qase provides end-to-end test management solutions under one platform.
• Users can create and organize test cases by allowing collaboration with team members.
• Test cases can be imported and exported easily with various file formats.
• It allows users to create detailed test plans with objectives and scope.
• Users can create multiple test runs by choosing the test cases and then can also group them into a test plan.
• Allows creation and management of members with access-based roles.
• Easy to integrate with popular tools such as Jira and Bugzilla.
• Users can log and track the defect within the system with a third-party integration feature.
• Generates detailed reports analytics with visualized graphs
• Users can create a dashboard with key metrics and trends
• Supports customizable workflows and versioning
• Provides API to integrate with other systems
• Supports CI/CD integration for integrated automation tools

Limitations of Qase

Qase provides many features however as the tool is still growing and has not reached maturity level there are many limitations. Below are some of the limitations of Qase.

• The tool has integrated many features into a single platform which may confuse users.
• If users are using the test management system for the first time, Qase may demand a good amount of learning.
• Though it supports API integration, it puts a restriction on the rate limit.
• Large teams may face performance issues that Qase may not be ready to handle yet.
• Though it supports integration with multiple tools, integration may be challenging and requires technical proficiency.
• Small organizations and start-ups may be concerned about subscription costs.
• Qase limits the customization of reports and dashboards. Though it allows customization it may not be enough especially when an organization is large.
• It lacks the AI/ML feature.
• Qase features may not fulfill large-scale organizational needs, especially when requirements are complex.
• Qase integration support is limited, and legacy tool integration may be challenging.
• Many features are still under development.

Features of Testsigma

Testsigma initially started as a no-code test automation tool and it has quickly become popular in the automation testing space. As always Testsigma is aggressive in releasing the new feature and never compromises on the feature delivery. It recently launched a Test Management System, with many unique features. With the test management feature for manual testing, Testsigma now supports both manual and automation use cases natively. As Testsigma supports both manual and automation scripting natively its features are non-exhaustive however in this section we are trying to focus on manual testing and test management features.

• It is a cloud-based tool for test management with minimal configurations.
• A rich and intuitive user interface to write test cases.
• Self-explanatory navigations and very little learning curve.
• Advanced technology with AI-driven test management tools.
• UI-based filters allow quick filtering out test cases based on requirements.
• The AI-based feature allows generation of test cases using text or images.
• Allows to group the test cases based on the given criteria.
• Step groups allow us to reduce the effort of writing repetitive test cases and increase productivity.
• Easy to create test runs, and you can assign and track the test runs in real time.
• Supports modern agile-based in-sprint testing.
• Mark the test cases instantly pass, fail, untested, etc., and filter out whenever required.
• Integration with Jira allows creation of the defect from Testsigma without navigating to the Jira board.
• Attach the evidence and comment based on the test execution outcome.
• Create a Test plan based on the release requirement add as many as test runs you want
• Track and monitor the test runs in real-time.
• Comprehensive real-time dashboard to track and monitor the progress of the test life cycle.
• Create a report and share it with the stakeholders.

Testsigma vs Testomat vs Qase – Table Comparison

The table comparison helps to understand the differences between 3 products and choose the best one based on the requirement

Features	Testsigma	Testomat	Case
Setup	Easy to set up	Complex setup and requires technical expertise	Complex setup and requires technical expertise
Usage	Easy and intuitive design	Rich interface however navigation might be confusing at times	Good user interface
AI-based test creation	Yes, allows the creation of the tests using the text or image format	No support for AI-based test creation	No support for AI-based test creation
Test step grouping	Allows to group the test steps and increase the reusability of existing test cases	No support for Step-group	Supports test group
Integration support	Supports integration with many tools including Jira	Supports integration with Jira, Jenkins, and other tools	Supports integration with Jira, Bugzilla, and other popular tools
In-built test automation support	Testsigma offers both a no-code test automation platform and test management for manual testing	No support for in-built test automation. But supports third-party automation tools	No Support for in-built test automation supports only third-party automation tools
Test Plans and Test runs support	Yes, supported	Yes, Supported	Yes, Supported
Cost and Billing	Flexible cost and billing	Offers Free, Enterprise, and Professional plans to choose from across	Offers Free, Startup, Business, Enterprise plans
Customer Support	Email, Live Chat, Help Centre	Email	Live support

Testsigma vs Testomat vs Qase – Which one to Choose?

Testomat, Qase, and Testsigma all of these are modern test management tools, they offer good features. However, many factors can impact productivity such as learning curve, ease of use, and supported features. Testsigma always focuses on ease of use and a low learning curve. Additionally, Testsigma offers flexible pricing plans by understanding the business needs. Testsigma is aggressive in delivering the features, by listening to the customer it delivers the required features in a shorter time. Though Testomat and Qase are good tools to choose from, they may lack many advanced capabilities such as AI-based test case creation, image-based test case creation, etc. The Test management tool requirement may change based on the organization’s requirement and type of the project; one can choose any of these tools that can fit the best into the project after analyzing the requirement.

Conclusion

Test Management tools allow for an increase in the productivity and speed of the testing life cycle. Test management tools help to streamline the testing process by providing the feature to collaborate with the Business Analysts, Developers, QA, and Product Team in the early stage of software development. Many tools in the market support Test management but some of them are outdated and they cannot compete with modern changing business requirements. Some tools are adapting to the changing requirements by integrating advanced features such as AI, text-based test creation, image-based test creation, etc. Testsigma is one of these tools that is known for its simplicity, budget-friendliness, and advanced capability. Additionally, it is an all-in-one platform that supports both manual testing and automation testing natively without third-party tool requirements. It also supports integration with many tools that are required to fulfill the testing needs. 

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Testsigma a Test Management System or an Automation Platform?

Testsigma is an all-in-one tool that supports both automation and manual testing under a single platform. It offers many features such as planning, designing, and execution of manual test cases. Similarly, it also provides the capability of designing, creating, and executing automation test cases. In short, it supports both Test Management System (Manual Testing) and Automation under its platform

Does Testsigma support in Sprint testing?

Yes, Testsigma supports in-sprint testing by allowing testers to create, manage, and execute the test cases within the sprint. It supports many features including test step grouping that can reduce the amount of work for testers, and testers will be able to deliver even with a tight schedule.

Is Jira a test management tool?

Jira is a project management tool that can be used for test management by integrating third-party applications. 

Which tool is used for test management?

Testsigma can be used for Test Management to reduce the delivery time and increase productivity

What is meant by test management?

Test management is a terminology used to manage testing activities which includes test planning, test designing, and test execution. It may require collaboration from other teams such as business, product, development, and testing teams.